Insurance: December 2007 Archives

Mr. Kattoum so annoyed his wife that she intentionally drove the family Lincoln into the wall of the family car wash business. When the couple had the chutzpah to file an insurance claim, the company declined, relying on a provision in part A of the Policy  which read: "We do not provide liability coverage for an insured . . . who intentionally causes property damage." But there was no such language in the casualty coverage provisions in Part D. The Florida Appeals Court rightly held it was error to incorporate an intentional damage exclusion from one subpart of a policy to another. Taisyer Kattoum v. New Hampshire Indemnity Co. (Fla. 2d DCA Case No. 2D05-3526, Opinion Filed Sept. 28, 2007).

The Maryland Court of  Special Appeals issued an opinion helpful to insureds in Maryland Casualty Co. v. Hanson. The case involved the issue of continuous trigger: whether continuous  exposure or damage constitutes a single or multiple losses such that the more than one insurance policy is stacked or whether the policy’s “limitation of liability” provision concerning repeated exposure or damage as one occurrence limits the available insurance coverage.

Continuous trigger is a relatively new idea in the law and concerns an issue important to landowners where there has been repeated injury or damage over time. Under the theory of continuous trigger, coverage is triggered during any time of exposure: initial exposure, continuing exposure or, in the case of property damage, by manifestation of loss.

In  Hanson, the plaintiffs were children exposed to lead paint at defendant’s property over six years, spanning several insurance policies. The Maryland Court of Special Appeals held that insurance coverage is triggered during all applicable policy periods in a case of continuous exposure and that the insured’s current carrier was on the entire risk.

Maryland Casualty Co. v Hanson. http://www.courts.state.md.us/opinions/cosa/2006/819s05.pdf

 

About this Archive

This page is a archive of entries in the Insurance category from December 2007.

Insurance: January 2008 is the next archive.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Insurance: December 2007: Monthly Archives

Powered by Movable Type 4.01